|
Claim Analysis Report
Parent/Educator View · 2024-12-28
|
Student Jake |
Grade 6-8 |
Topic Health Product Claims |
Mode Coaching |
Findings 5 |
Duration ~8 min |
📋 Summary
Jake completed an Claim Analysis Coach session investigating claims about "Health Product Claims" in Coaching mode. Over approximately 8 minutes, they explored 5 of 5 investigation dimensions. With an Investigation Score of 8/10, Jake demonstrated excellent thoroughness - covering all five key angles of critical analysis. They explored: Source, Evidence, Reasoning, Context, Verification. Additionally, they spotted 5 specific persuasion techniques, earning bonus points. Their standout finding identified "" - demonstrating the ability to recognize specific persuasion tactics. The coaching mode guided them through systematic investigation phases. With this strong foundation, they can tackle increasingly complex claims.
🔍 Statement Investigated
"SuperBoost Energy Drink increases your immunity by 300%! Thousands of doctors recommend it. Don't miss out - this limited-time offer ends soon! 9 out of 10 users report feeling healthier within just 3 days."
📊 Score Breakdown
⚖️ Analyst
Above average for Grade 6-8
|
Technique Bonus: 5 techniques spotted = +1.5
6.5 + 1.5 = 8.0
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
📖 What Jake Learned
Spotting Vague Authority
The ad says 'thousands of doctors' but doesn't name any specific doctors
Real endorsements include names and credentials. 'Thousands of experts' without specifics is usually made up.
Questioning Statistics
How do you even measure immunity?
Always ask HOW something was measured. Percentages without methodology are often meaningless.
Recognizing Pressure Tactics
They're using 'limited time offer' to pressure people
Urgency tactics ('Act now!', 'Limited time!') are designed to bypass your critical thinking.
How to Continue the Conversation
Jake did excellent work spotting multiple persuasion techniques in a health product ad. Ask them to explain what 'vague authority' means and why it's a red flag.
Try This: Ad Detective Challenge
(10-15 minutes)
- Find a TV commercial or social media ad together
- Have Jake identify at least 2 persuasion techniques
- Discuss: What is the ad NOT telling us?
- Research: Can the claims be verified?
Conversation Starters:
"What was the sneakiest trick you spotted in the ad today?"
"Why do you think companies use fake statistics?"
"How would you redesign this ad to be more honest?"
What to Praise:
Jake asked 'How do you measure immunity?' - this is exactly what scientists ask!
Try saying: I love how you questioned where their numbers came from. That's real critical thinking!
Next Skill: Emotional Manipulation Detection
Many ads use fear or excitement to bypass logical thinking
Ask: "What emotions is this ad trying to make you feel?"
📈 Jake's Progress
| Score | Date | Topic |
|---|---|---|
| 4.5/10 | 2024-12-08 | Social Media Influencer (AA) |
| 6.0/10 | 2024-12-15 | News Headline Analysis (AA) |
| 7.2/10 | 2024-12-22 | Celebrity Endorsement (AA) |
| 8.0/10 | 2024-12-28 | Health Product Claims (current) |
+3.5 points improvement over 4 sessions!
See More Sample Reports
📐 Methodology
The Analysis Score measures investigation across 5 dimensions:
• 🔍 Source Check (1.5 pts): Who's making the claim? Any bias or conflicts?
• 📊 Evidence (2.0 pts): What proof is given? Is it solid or anecdotal?
• 🧠 Reasoning (2.0 pts): Does the logic hold up? Any gaps or fallacies?
• 🌐 Context (1.5 pts): What alternatives or viewpoints are missing?
• ✓ Verification (1.5 pts): How could we fact-check this claim?
Quality Levels:
• Basic = 50% of points (mentioned but didn't dig deep)
• Insightful = 100% of points (specific observations about the statement)
Technique Bonus: +0.3 per trick identified (max +1.0)
Maximum score: 9.5 pts. A 10/10 requires exceptional work across all dimensions.